There is generally a lot of talk about community, making them strong, the future of our communities, purchasing large buildings, doing fundraisers to open new centers, etc. ā but can these projects really turn into anything substantial and meaningful without the presence of regular congregational prayers as a prerequisite?
ŁŁŁ ŁŲ§ Ų®ŁŁŁŁŁŲŖŁ Ł±ŁŁŲ¬ŁŁŁŁ ŁŁŁ±ŁŁŲ„ŁŁŲ³Ł Ų„ŁŁŁŁŲ§ ŁŁŁŁŲ¹ŁŲØŁŲÆŁŁŁŁ
[51:56]Ā I did not create the Jinns and the human beings except for the purpose that they should worship Me.
Without worship, there is no spiritual progress and the purpose of life is not fulfilled. This is particularly true for obligations, such as the į¹¢alÄt and į¹¢awm. Obligatory acts of worship keep us upright and prevent us from crumbling down, while the recommended acts of worship serve as a means to further beautify and excel in achieving our purpose in life. If our obligations are not being fulfilled properly, or if one is not strong in performing them, yet one keeps adding on recommended acts of worship, the ability to perform obligations generally becomes weaker and shakier, as they were not built on strong foundations to begin with.
In fact, the foundation may even break and all that may remain is the rubble of recommended acts without any structure to hold them up and give them direction. This is also why many obligations have a qaįøa, because the essence of man is dependent on them, and if they are missed, humans become shaky in their foundations. The qaįøÄ is there to ensure that does not happen.
The most important act of worship in Islam is į¹¢alÄt. Its practice can be traced back to the very beginning of the Prophetās (p) mission after having been sent revelation. Multiple reports inform us that the Prophet (p) would pray in the vicinity of the Kaāba alongside his wife Khadija (s) and Ali (a), making it, one of the only few major obligations upon the Muslims during the Makkan period.
The į¹¢alÄt is such an important act of worship, that some reports mention that if it is accepted, other acts are accepted, and if it is rejected, other acts are rejected.2Ā It is similar to a pole holding up a tent.3Ā It prevents one from falling into indecencies,Ā [29:45]Ā ā¦establish į¹¢alÄt. Surely į¹¢alÄt restrains from shamelessness and evil ā if it is strong, its effects will also be strong as it removes these evils from humans. The better you perform these prayers the better their effects.
Three Contexts
When we look at the history of the į¹¢alÄt during the lifetime of the Prophet (p) we find three important contexts. The very first context was the fact that the į¹¢alÄt was meant to be performed by all Muslims when they did not have any power and authority. They were the minority, vulnerable and oppressed. Though there are scholarly disputes as to when the five daily į¹¢alÄt were actually made obligatory upon the Muslims, a vast majority believe it was made obligatory after the MiārÄj of the Prophet (p). There is no consensus on when the MiārÄj occurred, opinions ranging from anywhere between three years after the declaration of the Prophet to one year before the migration.
Reports that speak of the Prophet (p) praying before the incident of MiārÄj are either explained away as an obligatory duty for the Prophet (p) only and a recommended act for the few companions who followed along, or it is said that the į¹¢alÄt was obligatory upon all Muslims before the MiārÄj, but it was only 2 units, once in the morning and once in the evening. Some have cited the following verse as evidence for this explanation:
ŁŁŁ±ŲµŁŲØŁŲ±Ł Ų¹ŁŁŁŁŁ° Ł ŁŲ§ ŁŁŁŁŁŁŁŁŁŁ ŁŁŲ³ŁŲØŁŁŲŁ ŲØŁŲŁŁ ŁŲÆŁ Ų±ŁŲØŁŁŁŁ ŁŁŲØŁŁŁ Ų·ŁŁŁŁŲ¹Ł Ł±ŁŲ“ŁŁŁ ŁŲ³Ł ŁŁŁŁŲØŁŁŁ Ł±ŁŁŲŗŁŲ±ŁŁŲØŁ
[50:39]Ā So, bear with patience what they say, and proclaim His purity along with your Lordās praise before sunrise and before sunset.
While these discussions do not concern us in this paper, what we can acknowledge is that the Muslims nevertheless still engaged in some form of į¹¢alÄt on an individual level in Makkah. This is despite the constant torture and oppression they were encountering. There are reports which speak of the harassment of the Prophet (p) and as well as some of the companions during prayers in Makkah. A report inĀ TÄrÄ«kh al-TabarÄ«Ā records the following event:
āI said to āAbdullah b. āAmr, āTell the worst thing which you saw the polytheists do to the Messenger of God.ā He said, āUqbah b. AbÄ« Muāayt came up while the Messenger of God was by the Kaāba, twisted his robe around his neck, and throttled him violently. AbÅ« Bakr stood behind him, put his hand on his shoulder, and pushed him away from the Messenger of God. Then he said, āPeople, would you kill a man because he says, My Lord is God? ā¦ ā to the words āGod guides not one who is prodigal, a liar?āā4
A report in the SÄ«rah of Ibn Isįø„Äq reports how AbÅ« Jahl came very close to killing the Prophet (p) with a rock while he (p) was praying:
āā¦the leading men of every clan of Quraysh ā āUtba b. RabÄ«āa, and Shayba his brother, and AbÅ« SufyÄn b. įø¤arb, and al-Naįør b. al-įø¤arith, brother of the BanÅ« āAbd al-DÄr, and AbÅ« al-BakhtarÄ« b. HishÄm, and al-Aswad b. al-Muį¹į¹alib b. Asad and Zamaāa b. al-Asad, and al-WalÄ«d b. al-MughÄ«ra, and Abu Jahl b. HishÄm, and āAbdullah b. AbÅ« Umayya, and al-āÄį¹£ b. WÄāil, and Nubayh and Munabbih, the sons of al-įø¤ajjÄj, both of Sahm, and Umayya b. Khalaf and possibly others ā gathered together after sunset outside the Kaāba. They decided to send for Muhammad and to negotiate and argue with him so that they could not be held to blame on his account in the future.
“When they sent for him the apostle came quickly because he thought that what he had said to them had made an impression, for he was most zealous for their welfare, and their wicked wat of life pained him. ā¦ When the apostle had gone AbÅ« Jahl spoke, making the usual charges against him, and saying, āI call God to witness that I will wait for him tomorrow with a stone which I can hardly lift,ā or words to that effect, āand when he prostrates himself in prayer I will split his skull with it. Betray me or defend me, let the BanÅ« āAbd al-ManÄf do what they like after that.āĀ They said that they would never betray him on any account, and he could carry on with his project.
“When morning came AbÅ« Jahl took a stone and sat in wait for the apostle, who behaved as usual that morning. While he was in Makkah he faced Syria in prayer, and when he prayed, he prayed, he prayed between the southern corner and the black stone, putting the Kaāba between himself and Syria. The apostle rose to pray while Quraysh sat in their meeting, waiting for what AbÅ« Jahl was to do. When the apostle prostrated himself, AbÅ« Jahl took up the stone and went towards him, until when he got near him, he turned back in flight, pale with terror, and his hand had withered upon the stone, so that he cast the stone from his hand.ā5
There are also reports that describe how the companions of the Prophet (p) had to conceal their į¹¢alÄt from the polytheists in fear of repercussions. Consider the following report fromĀ al-TabaqÄtĀ of Ibn Saād:
āMuį¹£āab heard that the Prophet was inviting people to Islam in the house of Arqam b. AbÄ« Arqam, he went to the house where he accepted Islam and believed in the Prophet. After leaving the house, he kept his conversion a secret for fear of his mother and his family.Ā He frequently visited the Prophet in secret but āUthmÄn b. į¹¬alįø„a once saw him performing į¹¢alÄt and informed his mother and family about it. They therefore captured him and kept him jailed until he finally managed to migrate to Abyssinia with the first group of Muslim immigrants.Ā He later returned to Makkah with the other Muslims but his condition had changed because he lived a difficult life. His mother then stopped rebuking him.ā6
Despite the troubles the Muslims were going through, the į¹¢alÄt was kept up by them as an individual duty. This is the very first initial context for the į¹¢alÄt in the Prophetās (p) biography and before the formation of a Muslim community.
In a second context, we find that the Muslims also eventually began praying in a congregation ā whether these congregational prayers were being performed with all their rules and conditions as observed today or just as a group of Muslims gathering together to perform their individual prayers is not clearly known, but at the very least we know there were instances the Muslims would gather to pray alongside one another. This second phase also occurs in the Makkan phase and depicts the extent to which the Muslims went to ensure the prayers were being performed, not just individually, but also as a group.
One incident that shows how the Muslims would gather to pray together is in fact a well-known event that has been used by some critics of Islam to argue it was the Muslims who initiated violence and aggression against the polytheists. The report is mentioned inĀ TÄrÄ«kh al-TabarÄ«Ā as follows:
āWhen the Messenger of Godās Companions prayed they went to the ravines and concealed themselves from their fellow tribes-men. Once while Saād b. AbÄ« WaqqÄs and a number of the Messenger of Godās Companions were in one of the ravines of Makkah, a group of polytheists suddenly appeared before them as they were praying, expressed their disapproval and reproached the believers for what they were doing. Finally, they came to blows and Saād b. AbÄ« WaqqÄs struck one of the polytheists with a camelās jawbone and split his head open. This was the first bloodshed in the time of Islam.ā7
The group of Muslims had gone to the outskirts of Makkah to engage in worship and the į¹¢alÄt and the report shows that it was in fact the polytheists who went out of their way to harass the Muslims. Another version of the above incident is also recorded in the SÄ«rah of Ibn Isįø„Äq as follows:
āWhen the apostleās companions prayed they went to the glens so that their people could not see them praying, and while Saād b. AbÅ« WaqqÄs was with a number of the Prophetās companions in one of the glens of Mecca, a band of polytheists came upon them while they were praying and rudely interrupted them. They blamed them for what they were doing until they came to blows, and it was on that occasion that Saād smote a polytheist with the jawbone of a camel and wounded him. This was the first blood to be shed in Islam.ā8
It would not be far-fetched to assume the insistence on the į¹¢alÄt as a congregation, even in Makkah in a context where the Muslims were persecuted, was due to the encouragement revealed in the QurÄnic verses. Despite the persecution, it is well known that Muslims did not have permission to fight back the polytheists physically. Yet the į¹¢alÄt was not abandoned in both these two contexts in Makkah ā individually or congregationally. A verse of the QurÄn highlights the sentiment that some Muslims wanted to fight back, but were told if you wish to fight back, you must first prepare and ready yourself; this preparation has to be done through patience, and patience entails establishing (iqÄmah) the į¹¢alÄt. The QurÄnic expectation appears to be that if congregational prayers are established, this will eventually lead to a congregational movement. We read in Surah al-NisÄā:
Ų£ŁŁŁŁ Ł ŲŖŁŲ±Ł Ų„ŁŁŁŁ Ł±ŁŁŁŲ°ŁŁŁŁ ŁŁŁŁŁ ŁŁŁŁŁ Ł ŁŁŁŁŁŁŁŲ§Ū Ų£ŁŁŁŲÆŁŁŁŁŁŁ Ł ŁŁŲ£ŁŁŁŁŁ ŁŁŲ§Ū Ł±ŁŲµŁŁŁŁŁŁ°Ų©Ł ŁŁŲ”ŁŲ§ŲŖŁŁŲ§Ū Ł±ŁŲ²ŁŁŁŁŁŁ°
[4:60]Ā Have you (O Prophet) not seen those who had been told, āDo not fight! Rather, establish prayer and pay alms-tax?
This second context is crucial, particularly as it pertains to Muslims engaging in worship in a congregation where they are not yet in power. In many places, we have prohibitions and limitations to an extent where we cannot easily spread the message of Islam in the most ideal manner, and the QurÄn considers this to be a period of patience. Yet in this context of patience, the Islamic injunctions have asked us to establish prayers in a congregational format, and the historical data shows that this what the persecuted Muslims did as they are asked to observe patience by establishing the į¹¢alÄt and paying the zakÄt.
It is also important to note that establishing prayers is different than performing the prayers. Establishing prayers implies the coming together in the hope that Muslims would arrive at a unity and eventually form into a cohesive community. Where one is a minority and in a vulnerable position, such that they cannot fight back nor establish a government, Islam considers the establishment of congregational prayers tantamount to fighting back.
The third context of the į¹¢alÄt occurs after the migration of the Prophet (p) to Medina. In this context, we see that the į¹¢alÄt is being performed by Muslims after gaining authority and power. This is the third stage and the QurÄn also describes what is expected from those who are granted such authority in Surah al-įø¤ajj:
Ł±ŁŁŁŲ°ŁŁŁŁ Ų„ŁŁ Ł ŁŁŁŁŁŁŁŁŁŁ°ŁŁŁ Ł ŁŁŁ Ł±ŁŁŲ£ŁŲ±ŁŲ¶Ł Ų£ŁŁŁŲ§Ł ŁŁŲ§Ū Ł±ŁŲµŁŁŁŁŁŁ°Ų©Ł ŁŁŲ”ŁŲ§ŲŖŁŁŁŲ§Ū Ł±ŁŲ²ŁŁŁŁŁŁ°Ų©Ł ŁŁŲ£ŁŁ ŁŲ±ŁŁŲ§Ū ŲØŁŁ±ŁŁŁ ŁŲ¹ŁŲ±ŁŁŁŁ ŁŁŁŁŁŁŁŁŲ§Ū Ų¹ŁŁŁ Ł±ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁŁŲ±Ł Ū ŁŁŁŁŁŁŁŁŁ Ų¹ŁŁŁ°ŁŁŲØŁŲ©Ł Ł±ŁŁŲ£ŁŁ ŁŁŲ±Ł
[22:41]Ā Ė¹They areĖŗ those who, if established in the land by Us, would perform prayer, pay alms-tax, encourage what is good, and forbid what is evil. And with Allah rests the outcome of all affairs.
In other words, even after being granted authority and the power to govern, establishing prayers is one of the first duties that has to be fulfilled. In fact, the success of the now developed community depends on its establishment. Given these three contexts found in the Prophetās (p) sÄ«rah, we can extract three functions for the į¹¢alÄt:
1) The į¹¢alÄt is a requirement for the survival of manās essence, and Muslims were individually expected to pray, initially as a highly encouraged act and eventually as an obligation. This was to be carried out even in the most severe circumstances and not to be given up on.
2) In a vulnerable position when one has no authority to fight back physically nor have a government at their disposal, it was still highly encouraged to engage in į¹¢alÄt, but in congregation. The į¹¢alÄt was the reason why Muslims would congregate even if it meant going on the outskirts of Makkah. Eventually, this congregational worship would lead to a stronger congregation and a congregational migration.
3) Once the Muslims gained power in Medina and the government was at their disposal, the congregational į¹¢alÄt was still one of the most fundamental duties performed because even the essence of a righteous government and the success of a community depended on it.
In all three contexts, we can observe the primary importance of the prayers, while other activities appear to be secondary and only to be sought once the į¹¢alÄt was established.
A Fundamental Identity of a Community
What we can extract from the life of the Prophet (p) is that congregational į¹¢alÄt was an observable identity of a Muslim individual and as well as the community. When we speak or refer to a Muslim or an Islamic community today, and we cannot identify them with the practice of congregational prayers, it would indicate that said individual or community at large is being negligent towards a very basic and fundamental matter. Such negligence would be considered a very significant flaw in the way the congregation and community are set up.
Prioritizing and being excessive in secondary activities in the absence of such a fundamental matter is similar to the example alluded earlier, regarding the rubble of a demolished structure. As per the sÄ«rah, the į¹¢alÄt is the most basic, and yet the most prioritized duty that had to be performed at all costs, given that the physical and spiritual existence and success of the community was dependent on it.
In a very profound narration, Imam RiįøÄ (a) sheds some light on the role of į¹¢alÄt in the early Prophetic community. He (a) says:
Ų„ŁŁŁŁŁ ŁŲ§ Ų¬ŁŲ¹ŁŁŁŲŖŁ Ų§ŁŁŲ¬ŁŁ ŁŲ§Ų¹ŁŁŁ ŁŁŲ¦ŁŁŁŁŲ§ ŪŁŚ©ŁŁŁŁ Ų§ŁŁŲ„ŁŲ®ŁŁŁŲ§ŲµŁ ŁŁ Ų§ŁŲŖŁŁŁŁŲŁŪŲÆŁ ŁŁ Ų§ŁŁŲ„ŁŲ³ŁŁŁŲ§Ł Ł ŁŁ Ų§ŁŁŲ¹ŁŲØŁŲ§ŲÆŁŁŁ ŁŁŁŁŁŁŁ Ų„ŁŁŁŁŲ§ ŲøŁŲ§ŁŁŲ±Ų§Ł Ł ŁŚ©ŁŲ“ŁŁŁŲ§Ł Ł ŁŲ“ŁŁŁŁŲ±Ų§Ł ŁŁŲ£ŁŁŁŁ ŁŁŪ Ų„ŁŲøŁŁŁŲ§Ų±ŁŁŁ ŲŁŲ¬ŁŁŁŁ Ų¹ŁŁŁŁ Ų£ŁŁŁŁŁ Ų§ŁŲ“ŁŁŲ±ŁŁŁ ŁŁ Ų§ŁŁŲŗŁŲ±ŁŲØŁ ŁŁŁŁŁŁŁ ŁŁŲŁŲÆŁŁŁ ŁŁ ŁŁŪŁŚ©ŁŁŁŁ Ų§ŁŁŁ ŁŁŁŲ§ŁŁŁŁ ŁŁ Ų§ŁŁŁ ŁŲ³ŁŲŖŁŲ®ŁŁŁŁ Ł ŁŲ¤ŁŲÆŁŁŪŲ§Ł ŁŁŁ ŁŲ§ Ų£ŁŁŁŲ±ŁŁ ŲØŁŁŁ ŪŁŲøŁŁŁŲ±Ł Ų§ŁŁŲ„ŁŲ³ŁŁŁŲ§Ł Ł ŁŁ Ų§ŁŁŁ ŁŲ±ŁŲ§ŁŁŲØŁŁŁ ŁŁ ŁŁŪŁŚ©ŁŁŁŁ Ų“ŁŁŁŲ§ŲÆŁŲ§ŲŖŁ Ų§ŁŁŁŁŲ§Ų³Ł ŲØŁŲ§ŁŁŲ„ŁŲ³ŁŁŁŲ§Ł Ł ŲØŁŲ¹ŁŲ¶ŁŁŁŁ Ł ŁŁŲØŁŲ¹ŁŲ¶Ł Ų¬ŁŲ§Ų¦ŁŲ²ŁŁŁ Ł ŁŁ ŁŚ©ŁŁŁŁŁ Ł ŁŲ¹Ł Ł ŁŲ§ ŁŁŪŁŁ Ł ŁŁŁ Ų§ŁŁŁ ŁŲ³ŁŲ§Ų¹ŁŲÆŁŁŁ Ų¹ŁŁŁŁ Ų§ŁŁŲØŁŲ±ŁŁ ŁŁ Ų§ŁŲŖŁŁŁŁŁŁŁ ŁŁ Ų§ŁŲ²ŁŁŲ¬ŁŲ±Ł Ų¹ŁŁŁ Ś©ŁŲ«ŁŪŲ±Ł Ł ŁŁŁ Ł ŁŲ¹ŁŲ§ŲµŁŪ Ų§ŁŁŁŁŁŁ Ų¹ŁŲ²ŁŁ ŁŁ Ų¬ŁŁŁŁ.
The congregational prayers were only legislated so that sincerity, oneness of Allah, submission, and the worshipping of Allah become obvious, known, apparent, and common, because the apparent manifestation of it will complete the proof [of Islam] upon the people of the East and West. [They were legislated so] that it will make the hypocrite and the one who belittles [the teachings of religion] humble and respectful to that which they have apparently confessed to, and cause them to express their Islam and submit to it.
[They were legislated so] that the testimonies of people regarding the Islam of one another become lawful and possible. Moreover, it becomes the [cause of] cooperation & coworking of them upon good acts and piety and their taking distance from the plenty of evil acts forbidden by Allah.9Imam RiįøÄ (a) explains that the į¹¢alÄt is meant to be prayed congregationally not just because it is a way to show servitude to Allah (swt), but because that is how the communityās religious identity is meant to manifest. This is important for us as it gives an opportunity to reflect whether when outsiders look at our communities and our year-long gatherings, regular programs, and functions, would they easily be able to identify us with the į¹¢alÄt or not? Or is it that they would perhaps predominantly identify us with other aspects, or perhaps they will realize that we do not even identify ourselves with the į¹¢alÄt, rather through matters which are either less prioritized in the teachings of Islam, or are meant to be prioritized at a later period once a cohesive community is truly established, or perhaps through matters that have no religious significance at all?
The Prophetic sÄ«rah alongside the QurÄnic verses show us the priority and role of the į¹¢alÄt in three very different contexts. This was the foremost priority for the Muslim community, and the QurÄn speaks about this in about 50 places ā the notion of establishing the į¹¢alÄt. As Muslims, we would need to really ask ourselves: are we really imitating the sÄ«rah of the Prophet (p) when it comes to community building?
There is generally a lot of talk about community, making them strong, the future of our communities, purchasing large buildings, doing fundraisers to open new centers, etc. ā but can these projects really turn into anything substantial and meaningful without the presence of regular congregational prayers as a prerequisite? Are we truly building communities and a congregation or are we merely facilitating the gathering of people for different occasions year long?
The attitude of holding a congregational prayer just because some coincidentally happen to gather on a Thursday night program or during some program commemorating the birth or death of a religious figure does not seem like an accurate attitude to maintain. In other words, the sÄ«rah seems to be indicating the centrality of the congregational prayers and in being the primary reason for congregating. The former attitude results in a degree of negligence towards the congregational prayers as they are seen as secondary, while the sÄ«rah expects us to congregate on the basis of the į¹¢alÄt and then use that as a stepping stone for secondary matters.
The Prophet (p) came and ensured this act of worship becomes the most prominent sign by which a Muslim and the community of Muslims is identified with. Part of the wisdom behind its legislation is that it leads to spiritual strength and refinement of the Muslims, which would then facilitate productive contemplative activities by the community and translate into something on the level of praxis and action. There are some significant points to reflect on, such as how much priority do we give it in our ācommunitiesā? Is this even a matter of discussion? In fact, if this is not a priority for a community and not considered as a central variable when making decisions to purchase and run a community centre, and if individuals do not prioritize their presence in a congregation, then according to the sÄ«rah of the Prophet (p), it appears we have very misplaced priorities and our perceptions towards the teachings of Islam have been skewed.
This article was originally published on Iqra Online, found here.Ā
Footnotes
- Creating a New Civilisation of Islam, by Jahangir Mohammed, pg. 57.
- WasÄāil al-ShÄ«āa, vol. 4, pg. 108
- Ibid., vol. 4, pg. 27.
- The History of Al-Tabari: Muhammad at Mecca, translated by W. Montgomery Watt, volume VI (6), page 102 ā 103.
- Ibn Ishaqās Sirat Rasul Allah ā The Life of Muhammad, translated by A. Guillaume, page 133 ā 135.
- Kitab al-Tabaqat al-Kabir, by Ibn Saād, volume 3, page 82.
- The History of Al-Tabari: Muhammad at Mecca, volume VI (6), page 88 ā 89.
- Ibn Ishaqās Sirat Rasul Allah ā The Life of Muhammad, page 118.
- āIlal al-SharÄāi, by Shaykh į¹¢adÅ«q,Ā pg. 97.