Art, Culture

I’m never going to like Mona Haydar’s “rapping” videos and you can’t make me

I thought we were done with these. I didn’t say anything last time but apparently, this is a thing now.

Let me start off by saying that I don’t know Mona Haydar. I’m not talking about her character or who she is; rather I am talking about her videos.

I will never like the videos of her rapping.

Neither her current video “Dog” or her previous video “Hijabi (Wrap my hijab)”.

…for this video to go as viral as it had, I was expecting bars. Sadly, it was bar deficient.

When the first video appeared on my timeline; I knew from the jump that I wasn’t going to watch it. As a Black and Latina Muslim Woman, I had been dealing with way too much at the time… every time I turned on the television, there was another person – who could be my own flesh and blood – lying dead in the streets. Couple that with issues I was having within the Muslim community, with race and racism, I was just not in a place to receive this video.

Somehow, one of my colleagues eventually got me to watch the video, and as I suspected, I was immediately over it.

As a child of hip hop, the rapping was sub-par. Not everyone is a Biggie or  Lisa “Left Eye” Lopez. But for this video to go as viral as it had, I was expecting bars. Sadly, it was bar deficient.

Furthermore, the topic of the video was something I was over.

As a Muslim woman who wears hijab, I am personally tired of being reduced to my hijab.

People’s obsession over hijab is frustrating at best and damaging at worst, both within the Muslim community and without. We, as Muslim women, are so much more complex than hijab.

I get it. Hijab is super popular in the media; both right and left, and we who wear hijab need comfort and support, especially in a Trump-era America. With so many hate crimes particularly aimed towards visible Muslim women, they are looking for an anthem; something that affirms them. However, there are Black Muslim women who are already on the scene rapping, for and about Muslim Women. Where is the viral love for Miss Undastood, Poetic Pilgrimage, or Alia Sharrief? Women who can actually rap? Why aren’t they on NPR, or having their videos go viral up and down my timeline?

AS

Rapper-feature.jpg

hijabihiphop.jpg

As if I couldn’t find more fault, I noticed that the only people dancing in that first video are two Black women. I’ve had some people make the argument to me that those two women are dancers, known as Al-taw’am, and that’s what they do. But if you zoom out, what do you see? You have two Black women dancing in the background, with a fair skinned Arab woman in the foreground, doing something which is a historical Black art form. We’ve seen this before: Iggy Azelia, Katy Perry, Taylor Swift. All have used Black bodies or elements of Blackness to bring “authenticity” to their videos.

Now, months later she has another video… and I still can’t do it.

This time there are no Black women pop locking and dancing behind her, but it’s still a no for me. Is what she “rapping” about important?  It sure is. Her video “Dog” is about trash men, and too many women I know have encountered men who one minute want to shame them, but the next are in their DM’s with unsolicited pictures. But do I think Mona needed to do another rap video? No. Not until the community allows the same grace and space for Black women to do the same, I don’t.

Not until the community stops pushing to the foreground fair skinned Arab women like her or Linda Sarsour, who are praised for their ability to be “down”, but silence Black women like myself and others, and not until we recognize that she is being given way more space and recognition than any other Black woman doing the same. Until our community can look itself in the mirror and make space for us Black Women, I can’t be on board, and I can’t apologize for that.

In the words of  Uncle Snoop, “It’s not fun if the homies can’t have none”.


This was originally published here on We Been Here.

11 Comments

  1. Mona’s songs are terrible, thats a given, but this piece of why they are bad is even worst – racist and unislamic to its core. Every line is written out of sheer jealousy of someone else’s success. That’s very Alt-right (or Alt-Left in this matter) mentality.

    1. Please elaborate as to how this piece is racist and unislamic. Please do elaborate and share chapter and verse as to how this is unislamic. Which ahadith are you pulling this from:

  2. I had never heard of Mona until now but I had heard of Poetic Pilgrimage… Black women rappers like them do have exposure

  3. Excellent review, I had the same reservations…sisters who don’t agree: move on. This is obviously the writer’s opinions and she clearly states why. Peace

  4. Could it be that she isn’t a proper rapper and that’s why people enjoy the one watch? Mona’s songs/videos are amusing and purposely humorous. It’s not really the kind of music too many will listen to on repeat. Maybe we can just stop tearing eachother down. Has it really not occurred to you that maybe it’s not her skin colour just this once but the material she’s producing that is giving her space? No one is stopping you or anyone else from doing the same.

  5. ive checked out all of the women artists you mentioned… unfortunately i cant relate to them like i can to mona.

    just as you cant relate to mona (and she cant relate to you)… in the words of a great black artist: “bitch, sit down”

    1. Watch your mouth. People can have a difference of opinion and Kiah needs not sit down but continue to stand all the way up and speak her truth. She isn’t tearing Mona down as a person but addressing her music.

Leave a comment!

%d bloggers like this:

Get more great content like this straight to your inbox!

* indicates required
Email preference *

Send this to a friend